Clinton's staff and Secret Service agents also went on these trips, which were to further the work of the Clinton Foundation, according to the statement. The prince said he was unaware of the warrant and that Epstein attended as Maxwells guest. You may also opt to downgrade to Standard Digital, a robust journalistic offering that fulfils many users needs. It's been widely reported that Gates had flown on Epstein's plane at least once, and visited his home multiple times but the depth of their relationship is not fully known, and more details are. Netflix, FX and Annapurna Pictures severed their ties with Siegal in July 2019 after her connection to Epstein became public, Variety reported. Melinda Gates met with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein alongside her husband, Bill, in New York City and soon after said she was furious at the relationship between the two men,. Before his death in 1967 he made his fortune as manager of The Beatles, as well as Gerry and the Pacemakers, Cilla Black and Billy J Kramer and the Dakotas. Lennon: "He was in love with me. Got some specific questions to ask you about Virginia Roberts., Maxwell replies: Have some info. The curiosity about the family biography is the issue of networking. The list released last week doesnt accuse all or even most of them of complicity with Epstein and Maxwells sex trafficking ring but at least 18 of the Does are listed as alleged perpetrators by one or both of the parties. Epstein even attended an 18th birthday party for Andrews daughter, Princess Beatrice, at Windsor Castle in 2006, two months after he had been issued an arrest warrant for sexual assault of a minor. Melinda French Gates had concerns about her husband's dealings with the convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein when she consulted lawyers to explore the option of divorcing the Microsoft. The magazine reported that Wexner allowed Epstein to take an active role in L Brands, which owns Bath & Body Works, Express, and Victoria's Secret. analyse how our Sites are used. Get latest information from around the globe. "In the summer of 2019, in light of the renewed media interest in the relationship, Mr. Staley volunteered and gave to certain executives, and the Chairman, an explanation of his relationship with Mr. Epstein," Barclays stated. Court documents unsealed on July 31 show Epstein accuser Virginia Giuffre testified that Clinton also visited Epstein's island - something the former president has denied. Two executors of Jeffrey Epstein's estate have been accused of moving some of the late billionaire and pedophile's fortune into a trust that could benefit them by at least $13 million. Registratie of gebruik van deze site vindt plaats onder Algemene Voorwaarden en Privacybeleid. Kellen, who also used the alias Sarah Kensington, allegedly served as the recruiter for the late convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. All Rights Reserved. WATCH LIVE: Ex-boyfriend on trial for allegedly killing womans new beau, WATCH LIVE: Psychic on Trial in Spousal Swindling Case, WATCH LIVE: XXXTentacion murder trial 3 men charged in 2018 shooting death of rapper, Law&Crime Looks Ahead to 10 Remarkable Criminal Trials Scheduled for the First Half of 2023, 9 Shocking Times Defendants Testified at Trial, A bald Alex Murdaugh appears in booking mugshot after hes sentenced to two life terms for killing wife and son, Im a father and I couldnt do this: Florida man convicted of murdering almost 3-month-old baby boy, Jan. 6th rioter who stole Officer Michael Fanones badge following Capitol assault pleads guilty, Former reality TV star gets life sentence for murder-for-hire plot targeting nephew, We really thought she was dead: Long-missing Pennsylvania woman discovered alive in Puerto Rico after 30 years, Billionaire Leon Black loses appeal of lawsuit that tried to turn tables on his rape accuser and her lawyers, Ghislaine Maxwell appeal claims she was prosecuted to satisfy public outrage over Jeffrey Epstein plea deal, jailhouse death, Billionaire Leon Black claims broad release clears him of one of two lawsuits accusing him of rape, 'I'm a father and I couldn't do this': Florida man convicted of murdering almost 3-month-old baby boy, Jan. 6th rioter who stole Officer Michael Fanone's badge following Capitol assault pleads guilty, 'We really thought she was dead': Long-missing Pennsylvania woman discovered alive in Puerto Rico after 30 years, 'Things went horribly wrong': Devastated family sues mortuary over wrongful cremation, Deutsche Bank officials went to Jeffrey Epsteins home for meetings when victims were present: Court docs, Explosive details of Jeffrey Epstein-related lawsuit against JPMorgan unsealed, revealing Snow White messages with former top exec, Deutsche Bank claims settlement deal with Jeffrey Epstein survivor shields them from lawsuit accusing them of complicity. How the biggest companies plan mass lay-offs, The benefits of revealing neurodiversity in the workplace, Tim Peake: I do not see us having a problem getting to Mars, Michelle Yeoh: Finally we are being seen, Our ski trip made me question my life choices, Apocalypse then: lessons from history in tackling climate shocks. Prince Andrew says he and Epstein were not that close. Epstein became a trusted confidant of Wexner's while Epstein managed the CEO's fortune, according to Vanity Fair. Photograph:(Twitter), US: Legislation authorising Joe Biden to ban TikTok advances. He has also been criticized for frequently taking flights on the taxpayer's dime while serving as the country's special representative for international trade. Lennon said it was the beginning of the end. The bipartisan political pressure to obtain a conviction was enormous.. Is Jeffrey Epstein related to Brian Epstein? Pre-trial witness subpoenas have been prepared for the five cases and could be served on the prince if he sets foot in the US again. Maxwell is a British socialite and the daughter of media tycoon Robert Maxwell. Jeffrey Epstein Madam Ghislaine Maxwell has ordered her attorneys to file an appeal to overturn sex-crimes convictions against her. Prince Andrew is alleged to have had sex with Virginia Roberts Giuffre for the first time at Maxwells London home. Brian Epstein was The Beatles manager as well as a friend. Andrew sat on another chair, I sat on his lap and he put his hand on my breast. The other girls all seemed and appeared to be under the age of 18 and didnt really speak English.. The plaintiff, a 62-year-old massage therapist, had died in September. Transcript: *This transcript was generated by a third-party transcription software company, so please excuse any typos. 1967 Brian Epstein Interview with Murray the K Astrid . Are there any resources someone could point me to so I can learn the known facts on these topics. Doe 023, for example, is someone who was subject to widely publicized criminal prosecution abroad for sex trafficking and later passed away, according to the document. During the criminal trial, one of the named victims testified that [Giuffre] and this individual, who were then both over the age of 18, recruited her at the age of 14 to provide massages to Epstein, Maxwells attorneys note in the document. The prince told Newsnight its very difficult to forget having sex with someone, because its a positive act for a man. J effrey Epstein was only a would-be Master of the Universe when I first met him in 1987, at movie producer Coco Brown's annual Halloween party in New York. "I don't question at all the decision of the state not to pursue the death penalty," Judge Newman said . As an accomplice, Epsteins ex-girlfriend, Ghislaine Maxill, was also arrested. After Jeffrey Epstein's July 6 arrest on sex trafficking and conspiracy charges, investigators have pored over the late financier's high-profile connections and multiple properties that could. There was speculation the pair were dating. Hoffman also implicated himself in the cover up of Epstein's donations to the MIT Media Lab. Gates said at The New York Times' Dealbook Conference in November that he believed "billions of dollars" would come from his meetings with Jeffrey Epstein. Although the two men are not directly related, they do share a common interest in raising money. In December 2010, the Duchess of York was given 15,000 by Epstein to help pay off her debts, just 18 months after he was released from jail for soliciting prostitution from underage girls. That appears to describe Jane, who claimed that Maxwell and Epstein sexually abused her when she was 14 years old. The emails show Epstein also worked as an in-between for other wealthy donors, including Bill Gates and Leon Black, and that Epstein had a role in determining what his donations would be used for at MIT, contradicting previous statements from Ito and the university. The result transformed the trial into a form of Kabuki theater designed to remind the jury at every turn that these adult women were being protected because their privacy interests, and not Maxwells constitutional right to a public trial, were paramount, the appellate brief states. Emailus. I think the Beatles experienced this level of fame/wealth/power, as did the Stones and all the others in their milieu. [emailprotected], Law&Crime's managing editor Adam Klasfeld has spent more than a decade on the legal beat. A 2011 letter to the Times of London from the princes then private secretary, Alastair Watson, suggests the pair knew each other from the early 1990s. Here are some of Epstein's most prominent connections: Bill Clinton Clinton and Epstein grew close in the first few years after the former president left office. After working for Wexner for seven years, Levin knew virtually every player on Wall Street (a few months earlier, Levin says, he . Have a tip we should know? Her mother was a singer whilst her father was a musician and ex-US Navy Chief Petty Officer. It's not something I'd count on. "He's a lot of fun to be with. The relationship between the Queens son and the late wealthy sex offender may have been closer than previously realised. Jeffrey Edward Epstein Gender Male Age 66 Date of birth Tuesday 20 Jan 1953 Birth place Brooklyn, New York, USA Date of death: 10 Aug 2019 Place of death In his prison cell at Metropolitan Correctional Center, Manhattan, New York City, New York, USA Cause of death Took his own life by hanging Occupations Investments and Finance Entrepreneur Buckingham Palace said in 2015 that the allegations against Prince Andrew were "false and without any foundation," according to the Guardian. I will take whatever actions are necessary in response to that, but I do want everything unsealed, Dershowitz added. Andrew claims to have no recollection of meeting Roberts Giuffre, despite being pictured with his arm around her in a now notorious photograph said to have been taken by Epstein. cookies It is important to emphasize that although Epstein was central to this criminal scheme, Ms. Maxwell is not being punished in place of Epstein or as a proxy for Epstein, Nathan said at the British womans sentencing last June, in a remark Maxwell would turn on its head on appeal months later. Epstein, who pled guilty to charges of solicitation of prostitution and procurement of minors for prostitution in Florida in 2007, ran a years-long trafficking pyramid scheme from the US Virgin Islands, prosecutors alleged in a lawsuit against the former wealth managers estate in January. In a statement to Business Insider, a spokesperson for Musk denied Epstein's claims of having served as an adviser to the CEO. Roberts Giuffre claims she was first trafficked by Epstein to have sex with the prince in Maxwells London home after dancing with him at Tramp nightclub. Maxwell is reported to have introduced the prince to at least one person he dated. Epstein was previously accused of procuring underage girls to sex in the past. Foto: Epstein with Maxwell. "I was a kind of plugged-in girl around town who knew a lot of people," Siegal told The New York Times. university The article contains emails sent between Ito and Epstein. Epstein didn't die until Aug. 10th. Although Epstein pursued Bill Gates aggressively, any account of a business partnership or personal relationship between the two is simply not true. That includes Prince Andrew's then-wife, Sarah Ferguson, the Duchess of York; and Charles Althorp, Princess Diana's brother. In the end, Giridharadas resigned from the Disobedience Award jury. Standard Digital includes access to a wealth of global news, analysis and expert opinion. If you are a survivor of sexual assault, you can call the National Sexual Assault Hotline at 800.656.HOPE (4673) or visit their website to receive confidential support. In evidence to a Florida court in 2015, Roberts Giuffre wrote: The third time I had sex with Andy was in an orgy on Epsteins private island in the US Virgin Islands. Hoffman not only sits on the Disobedience Award's jury, but funds it personally, according to the Media Lab's website. At that point, Brockman writes: I realized that the recipient of Irinas foot massage was his Royal Highness, Prince Andrew, Duke of York.. Is Jeffrey Epstein related to Brian Epstein? As pressure mounted on Media Lab director Joi Ito to resign, Hoffman defended Ito to author and fellow MIT Media Lab Disobedience Award jury member Anand Giridharadas in a private email, Giridharadas tweeted in September. Jeffrey Epstein is the former boyfriend of actress Giselle Wexner. Multiple people listed as Epsteins employees are said to have testified at his trial. The swirl of lawsuits, prosecutions and scandals have been brewing for decades, but its possible that the next batch of unsealed documents could turn up a number of previously unreported names. However, he is still being prosecuted in New York. Five Epstein accusers want him to give evidence in US courts, saying he must talk to the FBI. And unlike many others, Mr. Gates started the relationship after Mr. Epstein was convicted of sex crimes. Anyway, it seems any connection between Brian Epstein and Jeffrey Epstein is nonexistent simply due to how common the last name is. His parents were Harry and Malka Epstein. His inner circle includes Prince Andrew, ex-president Bill Clinton, as well as Donald Trump. But, if I do it, Im in big trouble, the emails describe him as saying. Last month, Sjoberg said she was prepared to share her claims with the FBI. Ghislaine Maxwell, a shamed sex trafficker and ex-British socialite, asked a US federal appeals court on Tuesday to overturn her conviction and sentence for helping late financier Jeffrey Epstein sexually abuse girls. One of them told multiple news outlets that he discussed that background with his peers during deliberations. Epstein left Bear Stearns to start his own company, Intercontinental Assets Group Inc. Epstein is alleged to have raped and robbed underage girls in the 1980s. Court documents reviewed by the Guardian allege that Epstein instructed Virginia Roberts Giuffre, a 15-year-old employee at Trump's Mar-a-Largo resort, to have sex with Prince Andrew on three separate occasions. An email exchange between Andrew and Maxwell, days after the prince was named in US court documents submitted by Roberts Giuffre, suggests he was asking for help in responding to the allegations. ALSO READ |US: Legislation authorising Joe Biden to ban TikTok advances, As quoted by ABC News, defence attorney Arthur Aidala said in a statement: "The government prosecuted Ms Maxwell as a proxy for Jeffrey Epstein. She started dating Epstein shortly after moving to New York in 1991, Business Insider previously reported. Wellmania. You can now write for wionews.com and be a part of the community. He began his career in finance at the investment bank Bear Stearns before forming his own firm, J. Epstein & Co. Epstein was a multimillionaire who was well connected with certain financial, political, and cultural elites. According to later reports, Epstein had attempted to be part of the recruitment for Victoria's Secret lingerie models. commentary and analysis you can trust. Law&Crime is not publishing her real name, as she has sought anonymity as an adjudicated victim of childhood sexual abuse. Some 15 are accused of having engaged in serious wrongdoing, and two alleged Epstein affiliates who arent accused of misconduct here are described as public figures. Nearly 90 are described as having been affiliated with Epstein, a victim, a witness or someone else. They are the John and Jane Does at issue in Virginia Giuffres long-settled lawsuit against Maxwell, who werent parties to the litigation but whose identities may become public. According to Giridharadas, Hoffman wrote in a second email that Giridharadas was making the situation "all about you" by threatening to resign. The event was attended by Katie Couric, George Stephanopoulos, and Chelsea Handler. Johanna Sjoberg claims Prince Andrew fondled her breast at Epsteins New York home on the same night as Roberts Giuffres second allegation, when she was 21. Although it has not been proven, it is clear that he was associated to some of the most powerful businessmen in the country. Though the document doesnt list any of the Does names, certain identities seem obvious from context clues. Epstein, Clinton, Spacey, and Tucker spent a week in 2002 touring AIDS project sites in South Africa, Nigeria, Ghana, Rwanda, and Mozambique for the Clinton Foundation, according to a New York Magazine report. As quoted by ABC and Fox News, the filing said: "In its zeal to pin the blame for its own incompetence and for Epstein's crimes on Maxwell, the government breached its promise not to prosecute Maxwell, charged her with time-barred offenses, resurrected and recast decades-old allegations for conduct previously ascribed to Epstein and other named assistants, and joined forces with complainants' civil attorneys, whose interests were financial, to develop new allegations that would support charges against Maxwell." Musk has confirmed crossing paths with Epstein at least once, Business Insider reported. Ghislaine put the puppets hand on Virginias breast, then Andrew put his hand on mine. Alle rechten voorbehouden. Emailus. Of the many mysteries that still surround the life and crimes of the notorious financier . He arrived in Britain with his parents, who emigrated from Lithuania to the United States. Getty Images Jeffrey Epstein's home at 9 E. 71st St. in NYC on December 1, 2021. His relationship with the Clintons is not entirely clear, but there is plenty of speculation that his relationship with the current president is more complicated than initially thought. Epstein started his career in New York City as a math teacher at the elite Dalton School, but in the 1970s, he went to work at the investment bank Bear Stearns before founding his own firm, J . I figured, what better community to ask than this one with 100k+ fans? Epstein also warned that both Musk and Tesla would deny their connection to Epstein if it ever became public, the Times reported. Aidala served as a defense attorney for Harvey Weinstein and is a frequent commentator on various news networks, including the Law&Crime Network. Eva Andersson-Dubin, an ex-girlfriend of Jeffrey Epstein's, on Friday denied suggestions of group sex with a woman who alleged that Ghislaine Maxwell facilitated orgies when the accuser was 14. His professional experience included consulting for the infamous Bear Stearns Ponzi scheme. An investigation by the Miami Herald revealed that Acosta, then a US attorney, had enough evidence against Epstein to request a life sentence. Business Insider previously reported that Acosta said he was "pleased that NY prosecutors are moving forward with a case based on new evidence," on Twitter. Have a tip or story idea? The question of how Jeffrey Epstein is related to Brian Epstein is one that remains unanswered by the public. [emailprotected], Law&Crime's managing editor Adam Klasfeld has spent more than a decade on the legal beat. Giuffres representative did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Both denied having had ongoing relationships with Epstein to Vanity Fair through spokespeople. You can still enjoy your subscription until the end of your current billing period. Bill Gates and Jeffrey Epstein met multiple times since 2011. US media reported that Maxwell's lawyers argued that the 61-year-old didn't receive a fair trial and was apparently used as a scapegoat because Epstein evaded justice, revealed a . Epstein was pronounced dead in prison in April 2019. Maxwell faced six criminal counts. Seizing upon those reports, Maxwell noted that the juroridentified in court papers as Juror 50 but named Scotty Daviddid not disclose his self-identification as a survivor during voir dire, depriving her lawyers of an opportunity to scrutinize potential bias. Jeffrey Epstein and Bill Gates. His reporting on the trial of Ghislaine Maxwell was featured on the Starz and Channel 4 documentary "Who Is Ghislaine Maxwell?" Maxwell told the judge she would not testify. Jeffrey Epstein is the convicted pedophile. In the resulting plea deal, Epstein served 13 months in a private wing of a county prison, which he was allowed to leave six days a week to work in his office. The claim: Jeffrey Epstein is alive and hiding in New Mexico. The Mogul and the Monster: Inside Jeffrey Epstein's Decades-Long Relationship With His Biggest Client. Try full digital access and see why over 1 million readers subscribe to the FT, Purchase a Trial subscription for 1 for 4 weeks, You will be billed 65 per month after the trial ends, Russian far-right fighter claims border stunt exposes Putins weakness, Germany seeks to buy Leopard tanks from Switzerland, Germany and Italy stall EU ban on combustion engines, Ukraine asks EU for 250,000 artillery shells a month, Russia on alert after reconnaissance group crosses over from Ukraine, Panic station at Fox News: how the Murdochs agonised over Trumps loss, Saudi owner of Londons most expensive house sued over alleged unpaid private jet bills, UK cabbage king turns to plant-based proteins, UK housing market braced for make-or-break spring, Airlines plan to sue Dutch government over Schiphol airport flight cap, There are no domestic equity investors: why companies are fleeing Londons stock market, Live news updates from March 3: Amazon pauses HQ2 construction, UK regulators launch LME probe, Deluge of inflation data pushes US borrowing costs to 2007 levels, FCA regulator blamed for Arms decision to shun London listing, Clutching Warrens letter, Im still positive on stocks, Joe Biden teaches the EU a lesson or two on big state dirigisme. In an interview with BBC Panorama, Roberts Giuffre insisted the photo was real, saying she gave the original to the FBI in 2001 and adding: Theres a date on the back of it from when it was printed.. Related Topics: Ashley Suppa Fashion Fashion Week Lisa Nicole Cloud New. Darren Indyke, Epstein's personal attorney, and Richard Kahn, the estate's in-house accountant, have long been accused of mismanaging his assets to avoid . Mutilated cats found across this Japanese city has sparked fear among residents: Reports, Three children stabbed, two others injured in Texas, As race to space 'shoots up' junk in Earth's orbit, US Space Command releases 'responsible space behaviours'. A friend was telling my other friend and I recently that Crowley is on the Sgt Peppers cover and that he has ties to a lot of our favorite 60s and 70s bands. . In 2017, MIT awarded Epstein and other donors "orbs" to thank them for their support, according to The Boston Globe. Prince Andrew denies having sex with teenager, saying he took daughter for pizza in Woking video, Virginia Giuffre: Prince Andrew's accuser asks Britain to 'stand beside her' video, Prince Andrew says he 'let the side down' over friendship with Jeffrey Epstein video, unearthed in a BBC Panorama investigation. The interview was widely criticized over Prince Andrew's lack of sympathy with Epstein's victims and his defense of his friendship with the convicted sex offender, Business Insider reported. It seemed weirdly coincidental that the Beatles' manager Brian Epstein died in 1967, a few years later another Epstein, Lee Eastman, became Paul's business manager. Multiple Does are said to have testified at Maxwells trial, including Doe 016 a victim who testified anonymously under a pseudonym. Some of the Does on the list are said to have been defendants in certain civil lawsuits, but some of those cases ended unceremoniously. Before trial began, Maxwell denied that she could get a fair trial given the massive public interest in her case, and her appellate brief delves into that topic. A spokesperson for Gates told Business Insider that "Epstein was introduced to Bill Gates as someone who was interested in helping grow philanthropy. This, in our current cultural moment, is epitomized by Jeffrey Epstein and his little black book. . Six weeks after Epstein was arrested for sex offences on 1 September 2006, the prince flew from London Luton to Edinburgh on Epsteins plane with Maxwell. At the event Founder Dr. Brian Mehling and CEO Doreen Santora were on hand to greet guests and discuss the new line over refreshments. As trial approached, the vilification of Maxwell was unprecedented in both scale and severity, the brief states. During your trial you will have complete digital access to FT.com with everything in both of our Standard Digital and Premium Digital packages. According to official reports he committed suicide, but there has been . In most cases, Giuffres attorneys are the parties designating a Doe as an alleged perpetrator, but there is one notable exception. Dr. Jeffrey Epstein is a world-leading expert in cosmetic surgery, aesthetics, and hair restoration based in Coral Gables, Florida. "He had achieved his wildest dreams but I don't think he . Ito worked with other directors and staff at the MIT Media Lab to quietly receive large anonymous donations from Epstein after he was convicted of soliciting underage girls for prostitution, a New Yorker expos published on September 6 reports. One case from 2020, which listed more than 35 defendants including Kanye West and Beyonce Knowles, was dismissed as frivolous. There is no indication that either of them is on this list of Does, or whether it would be significant if they were. It's not the one you think. A statement released in July 2019 by Clinton spokesperson Angel Urea said the former president traveled to Europe, Asia, and twice to Africa on Epstein's private jet. The Duchess told the Evening Standard: I personally, on behalf of myself, deeply regret that Jeffrey Epstein became involved in any way with me.. No doubt about it - Jeffrey enjoys his social life.". Musk and Maxwell were photographed at an Oscars after-party hosted by former Vanity Fair editor Graydon Carter on March 2, 2014, in West Hollywood. Spacey was also charged with sexual assault, but in December, The New York Times reported that the case had been dropped by the plaintiff's estate. 5 Common Causes of Clogged Drains (and What to Do About Them), 5 Tips For Caring For Human Hair Extensions, The Benefits of Minimal and Barefoot Footwear, 5 Factors to Consider Before Buying Kratom. Yes, THAT Jeffrey Epstein. The eldest son, Jacob, also went with them. Epstein's initials were removed from the wall . Gov. Two men who say they saw the original picture say it is genuine, but friends of Andrew told the London Evening Standard they thought it was fake, claiming Andrews fingers are much chubbier in real life. According to ABC News, the source that first broke the story Epstein. Your email address will not be published. Annie Farmer was the only victim to testify under her true and full name. The same year, Epstein and the prince partied with Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago, his residence in Palm Beach, Florida. Are they one family or is it maybe just a common last name? "He said it would be complicated to release the correspondence publicly because other names might get dragged in. Epstein, a registered sex offender and financier, was known for jet-setting with the likes of Bill Gates, President Bill Clinton, and Prince Andrew, the third child of the UKs Queen Elizabeth. This appears to refer to the testimony of Maxwell accuser Carolyn Andriano, who first testified only under her first name and then waived her anonymity in an interview with the Daily Mail. He died of a drug overdose in 1967 at age 33, three months following the release of Sgt. Epstein and Maxwell were making lewd jokes about Randy Andy I had sex with Andy there. In an interview published in the New York Times on August 12, Epstein claimed that Elon Musk had sought him out to help manage the trouble he had gotten into with the SEC a year earlier, in August 2018. Epsteins abuses are alleged to date as far back as 1985. She was convicted and received a 20-year sentence for helping late financier Epstein sexually abuse girls. It did so to satisfy public outrage over an unpopular non-prosecution agreement and the death of the person responsible for the crimes, Maxwells appellate attorney Arthur Aidala wrote in a 113-page legal brief.